Accommodations on the Island

The Cracked Mug

On the Square across from the Church.
Specializing in 3-course
5* breakfasts, a pillow menu, and unforgettable Island Experiences Open year-round for nightly BnB stays, plus month-to-month winter stays
Melanie Tucker (609)923-0304 Email:

The John Sterling Harbor House

5 Wharf Hill Road
next to the Island Inn
Mark & Susan Finkin
Enjoy complimentary hot breakfast while overlooking the harbor
(207) 596-2475 (on-island)
(518) 791-2838 (on shore)

The Monhegan House

Village Center
Across from the church
1870s Inn with Ocean and Meadow/Lighthouse Views
Restaurant open to public for
Breakfast and Dinner
Open May to October
Holden & Sue Nelson
(207) 594-7983

The Island Inn

On the harbor
Open Memorial Day weekend
to Columbus Day weekend
Rooms include Full Breakfast
Dining Room open for
Breakfast & Dinner

(Reservations required for Dinner)
(207) 596-0371

Brackett Rentals

Cottage Rentals island-wide
Mia Boynton & Lisa Brackett

The Trailing Yew

On Lobster Cove Road
Modified American Plan
Marian Chioffi, Manager
Open mid-May to mid-October
(207) 596-0440

Monhegan Cottage Rentals

Ocean Front Weekly Cottage Rentals
Maryann Boody
(207) 596-0175

Shining Sails

Bed & Breakfast
Rooms & Efficiencies
Ocean View
Continental Breakfasts
Rentals of Island Cottages
John & Winnie Murdock
P.O. Box 346
(207) 596-0041

The Inn at Fish and Maine

In the heart of the village
Harbor view Apartments with Kitchens
nightly or weekly rates
Weekly artist studio rentals
(207) 596-0041