Accommodations on the Island

The Cracked Mug

On the Square across from the Church.
Specializing in 3-course
5* breakfasts, a pillow menu, and unforgettable Island Experiences Open year-round for nightly BnB stays, plus month-to-month winter stays
Melanie Tucker (609)923-0304 Email:

The John Sterling Harbor House

5 Wharf Hill Road
next to the Island Inn
Mark & Susan Finkin
Enjoy complimentary hot breakfast while overlooking the harbor
(207) 596-2475 (on-island)
(518) 791-2838 (on shore)

The Monhegan House

Village Center
Across from the church
1870s Inn with Ocean and Meadow/Lighthouse Views
Restaurant open to public for
Breakfast and Dinner
Open May to October
Holden & Sue Nelson
(207) 594-7983

The Island Inn

Overlooking the Harbor, Manana and the Wharf since 1907. Open Memorial Day weekend to Indigenous Peoples’ Day weekend Rooms include Full Breakfast Dining Room open for Breakfast & Dinner (Reservations required for Dinner)
(207) 596-0371

Brackett Rentals

Cottage Rentals island-wide
Mia Boynton & Lisa Brackett

The Trailing Yew

On Lobster Cove Road
Modified American Plan
Marian Chioffi, Manager
Open mid-May to mid-October
(207) 596-0440

Monhegan Cottage Rentals

Ocean Front Weekly Cottage Rentals
Maryann Boody
(207) 596-0175

Shining Sails

Bed & Breakfast
Rooms & Efficiencies
Ocean View
Continental Breakfasts
Rentals of Island Cottages
John & Winnie Murdock
P.O. Box 346
(207) 596-0041

The Inn at Fish and Maine

In the heart of the village
Harbor view Apartments with Kitchens
nightly or weekly rates
Weekly artist studio rentals
(207) 596-0041